Updated for September 2023: The legendary Costco Pumpkin Pie is back again for Fall 2023. The Costco fan favorite pie is just as big as last year (and every other year before that) aaaaaand it’s inflation proof, still retailing for $5.99! The pumpkin pie is a Costco fan favorite item to serve throughout Thanksgiving, friendsgiving, Christmas and all the other holidays and family gatherings that occur this time of year. It’s huge, it’s good, and this super-sized pumpkin pie is definitely a crowd pleaser!
How Big Is It Really?
Big. A standard 9 in pumpkin pie Weighs about 22 oz…and the giant pumpkin pie at Costco weighs in at about 58 oz. That’s over three and a half pounds, and more than double the size of an average store bought pumpkin pie.
What We Like About It
On the whole, I think the Costco pumpkin pie is really quite delicious, in fact it’s so good that I don’t justify making one for our Thanksgiving meal because I really don’t think my own comes out that much better (if better at all).
I’m sure there are some special Family Recipes or special tweaks to the classic pumpkin pie recipe that it wouldn’t compete with…but if you’re looking to serve multiple desserts or host a large crowd, at some point you’ve got to outsource and find some good, solid store-bought items that you can serve and I think that the Costco bakery pumpkin pie stands solidly as one of those reliably good items.
I will note, that there’s a very comparable Sam’s Club 58oz Pumpkin Pie for $6.98 – so a buck more – if that’s more convenient for you.
How Many Servings are in the Costco Pumpkin Pie?
That’s a great question, and while it heavily depends on how large of pieces you cut…on average you should expect to get about 16 slices of pie out of a Costco pumpkin pie.
In many families, like ours, we serve multiple family favorite desserts at our Thanksgiving dinner such as apple pie and lemon meringue pie, so we tend to cut them a bit smaller so that each guest can try a mix of different desserts. In that case, you would be looking to get more like 18 or 20 slices from a Costco pumpkin pie.
Is the Costco Pumpkin Pie Good
Yes, the Costco pumpkin pie is a fan favorite item, and overwhelmingly Costco members like this housemade bakery pie.
What We Don’t Like About It
We don’t love the ingredients list (see below) – primarily the shortening which contains TBHQ. If this was an everyday household food item, we would not buy it because of that. For a one-off meal, a special treat…we do overlook this. We’d prefer a crust made with butter…but then it wouldn’t cost $5.99 so….I think that’s a choice each consumer needs to make.
Costco Item Number & Price
Costco Bakery Pumpkin Pie 58 oz is Costco Item Number 60809 and costs $5.99 in-store at Costco.
This represents zero price increase over 2021 and 2022! We have heard that the price can vary by location and cost a dollar more in some locations – we haven’t seen that ourselves, but mentioning – if your local store is charging $6.99 PLEASE drop a note in the comments and tell us! We would really appreciate!
Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Pie Features
- 58 oz
- Baked in-store at the Costco Bakery
- Signature pumpkin pie recipe
- Flaky Pie Crust
Costco Pumpkin Pie Ingredients
Pumpkin, sugar, water, eggs, enriched flour ( wheat flour, niacin, iron, thiamine mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid), shortening (soybean oil, mono- and diglycerides, TBHQ, citric acid), nonfat milk, contains 2% or less of the following: spices, corn syrup solids, modified corn starch, salt, canola and/or soybean oil, dextrose.
These are per the label on our pie…but PLEASE double check your label before purchasing 🙂
In the refrigerated cases in the Costco Bakery, you’ll find a super sized 72 oz…
Crowd favorite we’re reviewing today are the frozen Beef Costco Meatballs. The Kirkland All-Beef Italian…
Fall is coming, and that means pumpkin spice EVERYTHING season! And fan favorite Pumpkin Spice…
Quick and easy frozen fish option at Costco! This High Liner Tortilla Crusted Tilapia at…
Quick and easy side idea! Prepared Mediterranean Orzo Pasta Salad at Costco is a mix…
Costco muffins are a fan favorite! And the pumpkin streusel muffins at the Costco bakery…
Does Costco Still Sell a Giant Pumpkin Pie?
Yes, Costco sells their famous 3 1/2 lb pumpkin pie each year the fall season. For Fall 2022, the Costco pumpkin pie still costs $5.99, the same price as it was last year in 2021.
Does Costco Have Pumpkin Pie Now in 2022?
Yes, the Costco Pumpkin Pie is currently available in-store at your local Costco. In 2022, the 58oz pie costs $5.99.
How Much is a Costco Pumpkin Pie?
The Costco Pumpkin Pie costs $5.99 – $6.99 in-store in 2022.
Does Costco Make Their Own Pumpkin Pie?
Yes, Costco bakes their pumpkin pies fresh at their own bakery, using their own signature recipe.
How Many Calories are in the Costco Pumpkin Pie?
There are 320 calories in a 4.8 ounce serving – based on 12 servings in each pie.
Does Costco Still Sell a Giant Pumpkin Pie?
yes, Costco still sells their famous 3 1/2 lb pumpkin pie in the fall season. We see it hit stores around September 1st oh, and it stays in stores through the fall and winter holidays. this year, in 2022, the Costco pumpkin pie is still $5.99. it’s the same price as it was last year in 2021. There’s no inflation on the Costco pumpkin pie!