Costco Bakery Just Dropped a Banana Cream Pie that Weighs Over 3 Pounds!

Costco Bakery Banana Cream Pies - CostContessa New Costco FInds

The new Costco Bakery Banana Cream Pie weighs in at over 3 lbs, and features a graham cracker crust, banana cream filling, caramel whipped topping and a caramel drizzle on top. I can’t recall ever seeing a banana cream pie before – but let me know if you’ve spotted this previously at Costco…I think it’s brand new though!

Storage Note: The Banana Cream Pies need to be refrigerated (make sure you store this in the fridge!)


Costco pies are made fresh in each local Costco Bakery daily. You’ll find them in the open cold cases in the Costco Bakery department.

Costco Price and Item Number

The Kirkland Signature Banana Cream Pie costs $15.99 at Costco and is Costco Item #1826768.

Banana Cream Pie at Costco Bakery
Image Credit: Marie Clark


In my opinion, a banana cream pie is a pretty simple dessert and it really doesn’t need to have hydrogenated oils, corn syrup or palm oil. Banana cream pie is just a graham cracker crust, banana pudding/pie filling, and whipped cream – all of which can be made pretty simply with clean ingredients. I much appreciate that these are budget friendly, but personally I would be happy to pay a buck or two more and have it made without those ingredients.

See image below for complete ingredient list in the Costco Bakery Banana Cream Pie:

Costco Bakery Just Dropped a Banana Cream Pie that Weighs Over 3 Pounds! - CostContessa
Image Credit: CostContessa

My Thoughts

Costco uses cheap ingredients to make a lot of these bakery items as affordable as possible – I realize it saves money and that this is a fairly priced dessert for its size – and TRUST ME I buy these desserts sometimes too! [NO JUDGEMENT].

Personally, I have health conditions which limit my fat intake (especially junky fats) and I indulge in these Costco Bakery desserts sometimes, but I don’t purchase every single one. I tend to buy them when I’m feeding a crowd, bringing a pot luck item, etc. This time around, I did not purchase this.

I would prefer to make banana cream pie – plus it’s not baked which makes it a fun and easy pie to make with the kids!

If you bought it please leave your review in the comments!!

More New Costco Finds:

All opinions expressed on CostContessa are our own. Product features and nutrition information provided on our site is provided to us by third parties, and we do not independently verify its accuracy. Consumers should verify all information. Our content is not intended as a substitute for medical counseling or reading packaging yourself. Please always see actual package information yourself (it can and does change!) and consult your doctor with all questions.


  1. Was really looking forward to this pie. Hoping it was as enjoyable as the seasonal pumpkin pies. Unfortunately, I was very disappointed. ZERO banana flavoring. Like they completely forgot. I had feared a chemical banana taste but I can honestly say absolutely no banana flavor. I think the crust was tasty but is perhaps 30-50% too thick. Finally, both the “banana” and cream fillings are too sticky, reminiscent of the jarred marshmallow instead of a light whipped custard. I’ll stick to homemade using my favorite recipe from https://foodwishes.blogspot.com/2019/05/southern-style-baked-banana-pudding.html

    1. THank you so much for the honest review! I agree with sticking to homemade, I’ll have to try your recipe next time! Thanks again!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *